If you’re physically active or have long stretches of time in between meals, snacking doesn’t have to be a diet saboteur. The problem is that most people usually snack on the wrong things. Many of my clients tell me how they pack healthy snacks when on the go. “So what’s usually in your bag?” I ask. The more impressive responses are often a bag of carrot sticks, dried seaweed, kale chips, or a small box of organic blueberries. These are all good things but to have any sense of satiety you probably need to eat the entire bag or box (which is typically more than one serving size). None of these snacks are that high in calories, yet if you look at the carbohydrate or sugar content, it’s up there. Not to mention the protein is almost nil. So after having your treat, chances are you will still be craving something else. There is no fullness factor and it gives you no protection against being ravenous when meal time rolls around again.
Healthy-Marketed snacks are not always the healthiest options
The other responses I get regarding snacks are especially problematic for spiking insulin levels and fat storage. These include popcorn, rice cakes, granola bars, crackers and pretzels (even the organic/non-gmo kind). If you thought the carbohydrate content was high in the earlier snacks I mentioned, these “healthy marketed” options are even worse. Be careful of snacks like this which are very high on the glycemic index (an indicator on how food affects blood sugar) and also relatively low in nutrient value. Deficient in protein, these snack foods are quickly digested, converted into sugar and subsequently stored as fat. High carb snacks lacking protein often take hefty portions to be filling. So it’s easy to eat 2-3 servings in a blink while being totally unaware that this is calorically equivalent to a meal.
Nuts and Seeds
I happen to be a fan of nuts and seeds. Almonds, cashews, walnuts, pistachios, chia seeds, flax seeds etc. all have a home in my pantry, but you need to know if you can stick to portions. For many people, these snacks are off limits. Going to the health food store and scooping out these snacks by the pound from one of those bins into a plastic baggy can be trouble. It’s very easy to just eat right out of the bag without first portioning your servings. You can literally blow through hundreds to thousands of calories! Yes, these snacks all contain “good fat.” In large quantities, however, you are setting yourself up for weight gain. A handful of nuts or seeds is roughly considered a serving and equivalent to one ounce; just be sure you can stop right there. Be aware that all nuts don’t calorically come out to be the same.
Keep these nutritional facts in mind.
• Almonds are one of the least caloric nuts for their serving size. For a portion of 23, they contain 160 calories, 14 grams of fat and 6 grams of protein.
• Cashews are 17 nuts per serving for the same 160 calories and 14 grams of fat with about 5 grams of protein.
• Walnuts are a little more fattening with 14 halves as a serving equaling 190 calories, 18 grams of fat and 4 grams of protein.
• Pistachios, (although a little annoying to eat without a garbage can nearby) are the best calorically in terms of serving size. You get 46 nuts for 160 calories, 13 grams of fat and 6 grams of protein.
Peanuts
If you are interested in peanuts, they are technically not nuts; they are legumes. While they have some redeeming qualities such as healthy monounsaturated fats, fiber and nutrients good for preventing heart disease down the road, they are frequently contaminated with a carcinogenic mold called aflatoxin. From a weight loss perspective, they are highly caloric, not as nutritious as the other nuts mentioned and are very difficult to portion out.
So what about peanut butter and almond butter?
Almond butter over peanut butter wins, although it really depends what you put your almond butter on during snack time. Almond butter on rice cakes can be a diet disaster. For 2 rice cakes and 1 tbsp of almond butter on each cake, you will rack in over 300 calories and 20 grams of fat. I also have clients who like to stick a spoon in the peanut butter or almond butter and eat several bites (considering that their protein intake for the day). Five hundred calories and 50 grams of fat later, they wonder why they are gaining weight! A serving is just one tbsp. If you are disciplined enough to do that and make your spoonful last on a few celery sticks or an apple, then go for it.
Super Seeds
Chia seeds, flax seeds, or any kind of “Super Seed” can be a good source of fiber in a shake or a topping on your salad, but not something you want to snack on by the handfuls. At roughly 70 calories per tbsp, they make better pairings with other meals rather than a stand-alone snack.
Protein Powders
Protein powders can be a very smart snack but need to be chosen wisely. I like to carry a small shaker bottle with me to work with a single serving of protein powder. When my blood sugar gets low, I just add a little water and voila! I have a shake with no blender required. For caloric reasons, these powders should only be mixed with water and not milk, milk substitutes, or coconut water. Additionally, if you want to add a tbsp of seeds, a handful of berries, and/or some raw cacao, you need to calculate that extra pairing. Once you start making a “Super Shake” all tricked out with a million ingredients, it’s no longer a snack – it’s a meal!
Energy Bars
Energy bars – if chosen correctly – can save you on the go, but if you buy the wrong kind you may be eating something no better than a glorified candy bar. Additionally, make sure it contains at least 10 grams of protein. Many bars on the market are touted as healthy and natural because they are rich in nuts, seeds and fruit. A bar like this usually can run between 200-300 calories with 10-15 grams of fat and under 6 grams of protein. It’s a little deceptive because we associate nuts and seeds to be high-protein ingredients. After eating one of these bars, I promise you will still be hungry since it lacks protein and now you just wasted a few hundred calories. The higher protein, high-fiber bars will help to balance your blood sugar, keep you fuller longer and help you to eat less at your next meal. Just be careful to not have more than one bar a day since they can be addictive!
My other snacks of choice are:
• Edamame You can boil this at home and pack in a zip lock bag if on the go. It tastes good either hot or cold. One serving is around 180 calories with 17 grams of protein and 8 grams of fiber.
• Hard Boiled Eggs You can make them yourself or pick them up at most delis or convenience stores. One egg is around 70 calories and 6 grams of protein.
• Greek Yogurt The low-fat kind is around 150 calories and 20 grams of protein in a single serving.
• String Cheese An unprocessed, organic string cheese can be found at any health food store and is about 80 calories per serving and 6 grams of protein.
Rather than worry about the implications of snacking, the truth is that it can actually save you. It’s a good idea to have a high protein snack two hours prior to going out for a meal. That’s the biggest insurance for not regretfully overdoing it – especially at dinner time. We can try to count on self-control but it’s not reliable when you’re starving. At the end of the day we’re all like animals at feeding time. Without having a snack to reduce those instinctive urges to eat everything in front of us, we’re likely to consume way more than we bargained for. So that 200 calories you may have been afraid to invest in at snack time has now turned into an additional 1000 calories. Between the starters, bread and now finishing your entire entrée – you can easily blow your diet!